Sadly, I broke down and watched the American version of Skins because people were freaking out about it, and I wanted to see why.
This is all just my opinion:
First, obviously the people who are saying it's borderline child pornography have never seen the original version. The new version is a little racy, but it isn't any worse than all the reality shows on MTV.
Second, there are many issues I have with it:
The acting is pretty bad.
It's almost as bad as The Secret Life of the American Teenager.
Word-for-word and very similar scenes.
I can't remember everything in the first episode of the UK version, but I do remember the first scene, and the US version seemed to almost replicate it, but all the good stuff was edited out. Tony's sheets for example, were a really funny part of the show, and they've been replaced with spider sheets (not funny). I felt like they were also reading the script word-for-word from the original version but with the swearing and most of the British slang cut out, and it doesn't work. A lot of what they say sounds stupid with an American accent.
New character names and looks.
I don't like the new Cassie, or Cadie as they call her now. Why did they change her name, and why isn't she blonde? The ditzy, weird Cassie is more believable as a blonde. I don't like Stan's new look either. I liked him as a nerdy weird guy. Now he looks all surfer-druggie.
The advertisement.
It's being advertised like it was created in the US, and there was never a UK version. Lame.
Honestly, the only thing I like about the show is the new character, Tea because she brings a different story line to the show. Her family is funny, and the mob thing is interesting. The last scene with her grandma in episode two was really good also.
I feel like if they wanted to make a successful American version of Skins, they should've gotten better actors, better writers, and they should've put it on HBO or Showtime. Overall, I would give it a rating of 6/10.
Unfortunately, in spite of all the flaws, I've become hooked on the show, and I'm still going to watch it because I'm weird like that.
No comments:
Post a Comment